Gold Dredge, Highbanker or Trommel?

Keene gold dredge with Honda engine floating in a creek, gravel caught in the sluice riffles

A pan and a hand sluice will take you a long way, but at some point you'll want to move more material in a day. That's where powered production gear comes in. Each of the three main options solves a different problem. A dredge pulls gravel up from the stream bed. A highbanker (also called a power sluice) brings water to gravel away from the creek. A trommel washes and classifies tough, clay-bound material before it reaches your sluice. Here's how each one works, based on manufacturer guides, and how to pick the right one.

When to move up from a hand sluice

Keene notes that a typical highbanker or power sluice can process nearly twice as much material as a medium-size sluice under optimum conditions. Production gear also lets you reach gold a hand sluice can't. Keene points out that early miners came to realize the deeper gravels in a riverbed were often richer than the surface gravel along the banks, and dredges are built to reach them. If you keep running out of time before you run out of good gravel, or your best material is underwater or far from the creek, it may be time to step up.

Gold dredges

How a suction dredge works

According to Keene, a portable dredge uses the venturi principle. A pump forces water through a tapered jet, and the high-speed jet stream creates a strong vacuum in the suction hose. Gravel is pulled up the hose and spread over a classifier screen at the head of the sluice. Smaller, heavier particles drop below the screen into slower water, while larger rocks and light material wash back into the stream. Hungarian riffles then trap the gold: as material flows over each riffle, an eddy current forms that lets the heavy material settle out. Keene says this self-cleaning action means that, under normal conditions, a dredge sluice needs cleaning only once or twice a day.

Keene describes the surface dredge, which floats on the water and pumps material up into its sluice box, as the most popular, efficient and versatile type. It can be run with or without diving equipment.

Suction nozzle or power jet?

Keene recommends a suction nozzle for extremely shallow water. With a power jet, water enters at the jet and discharge end of the hose, which Keene says gives stronger suction with much less hose friction, so you can pull longer hoses with a larger engine and pump. With a suction nozzle, Keene's suggested maximum hose length is about 20 feet.

Backpack and small dredges

  • Keene 2 in Backpack Dredge with Suction Nozzle: a Honda GX50 engine that can run up to five hours on a gallon of gas, a 100 GPM pump, and a 10 x 36 in sluice designed for fine gold. Includes 15 ft of suction hose and 17 ft of pressure hose. Rated at 1.5 yards per hour. Net weight 66 lb.
  • Keene 2.5 in Compact Dredge: built for shallow water and dry-land dredging. It has Keene's SN25 Bull Nose suction nozzle, a P90 pump, and a sluice with Miracle Matting. Optional folding legs (sold separately) let you leave the floats behind for shallow, narrow creeks.

Hand dredges and crevice tools

No engine at all? Hand-powered suction tools pull gold out of cracks and crevices.

Highbankers (power sluices)

How a highbanker works

Keene describes a power sluice, or highbanker, as a sluice box with a hopper and a classifying screen. A pump sends water through a high-pressure spray in the hopper that breaks up compacted material and dissolves clay. Keene's classifier bars are spaced about 1/2 in apart, so only minus-1/2 in material reaches the sluice. Because the pump can push water a long way, you can set up away from the water's edge, closer to where the gold is, instead of hauling buckets to the creek. Keene says its small pumps can deliver water hundreds of feet.

Dredge/highbanker combos

Many machines do both jobs. Keene notes that power sluices can be adapted to dredge by adding a suction hose and nozzle, and in most cases the same pump runs both. Some examples:

  • Proline 2 in Dredge/Highbanker Combo: an HP100 pump and Honda GXH50 engine. It has a large hopper with two spray bars for dry or clay-bound gravel, Nomad matting and triple classification. Proline notes many owners mount it on pack frames.
  • Proline 2.5 in Combo: Honda GX120 with an HP200 pump. Proline rates it at more than five cubic yards an hour as a dredge and calls it the smallest combo that can be fed continuously with a standard shovel.
  • Proline 3 in Combo: Honda GX160 with an HP300 pump designed for pushing water higher and farther, plus two triple-row spray bars and a removable grizzly.
  • Keene 2.5 in Combo Power Sluice & Dredge Kit: turns an A52 hand sluice into a power sluice or dredge. 71 lb.

12-volt and mini highbankers

One thing to know first: Keene says 12-volt pumps have very low head lift, so a 12-volt highbanker has to sit at water level.

  • Keene Mini Max Power Sluice Concentrator: a single 2200 GPH, 12-volt pump. Keene rates it at up to a quarter yard per hour as a power sluice, and it doubles as a concentrate clean-up machine. It folds to 36 x 14 x 7 in and weighs 23 lb.
  • Royal Gold 30 in Highbanker: takes full shovel loads. Its low 3-amp motor can run all day on a small wheelchair battery. It has four adjustable 24 in legs and can be set up as a recirculator with a reservoir (not included).
  • Gold Hog Piglet Mini Highbanker + Clay Claw: 20 lb, with matting already installed. It needs a 1.5 or 2 in pump rated at least 3,500 GPH (pump not included).
  • Carolina Claimer Highbanker: an 18 x 20 in hopper, adjustable grizzly, and a 12 x 36 in sluice with carpet. It's fully welded aluminum and sets up as a dredge when you're ready.
  • Mini Gold Pup Highbanker: 26 x 26 x 6 1/2 in, with an 1100 GPH pump and five hinged riffles. It collapses for storage.

Trommels

How a trommel works

A trommel is a rotating classifier drum. In Keene's KT10 description, material is washed in the feed hopper, then tumbled through the classifier drum, where spray bars and breaker bars break it up and screen it before it goes to the sluice. Keene builds the KT10 for tough material like heavy clay, rooty dirt and packed gravel.

  • Keene 10 in Trommel, DC Powered (KT10DC): two 12-volt pumps and a 12-volt drum motor. It's quiet, handy where gas engines aren't allowed, and set up at the water's edge. Keene says the KT10 can move up to one yard per hour.
  • Keene 10 in Trommel, Water Motor Drive (KT10WD): high-pressure water from a P90GH pump spins a water motor to turn the drum. Like a highbanker, it can be set up away from the water.
  • Keene KT10SA Sluice Adapter: connects the KT10 to a Keene 10 in sluice for a longer recovery run.
  • Carolina Trommel: runs by hand crank, deep-cycle battery or an AC/DC converter. It has a 7 in classification barrel with 3/16 in classification, a 3 in tilt and tilting legs. It breaks down for transport and weighs about 50 lb.
  • Gold Cube Trommel: a 12-volt motor designed for continuous use, with the spray bar outside the barrel. Gold Cube made it to take the shoveling out of pre-classifying feed for the Gold Cube, which likes 1/8 in material.

Pumps, hoses and fittings

Keene stresses that a dredge is a balanced system. The sluice should be sized to the engine and pump, and the hoses and jet should match too. A box that's too small for the dredge runs water too fast to catch gold. Keene's examples of balanced setups:

  • 2 in backpack dredge: a 100 GPM pump with a 10 in wide box
  • 3 in dredge: a 250 GPM pump with a 14 in wide box
  • 4 in dredge: a 275 GPM pump with a 16 in wide box

Keene also warns that high friction loss in the pressure hose kills suction, and that a dredge sluice should sit at water level. Find replacement parts in dredge and highbanker parts, and hose and clamps in hoses, fittings and clamps.

Check the rules before you run an engine

Rules for powered equipment depend on who manages the land, the waterway and your state. On federal BLM land, the rules (43 CFR 3809.5) generally count hand panning and non-motorized sluicing as "casual use," and anything beyond that may need more paperwork depending on where you are. Before you set up a dredge, highbanker or trommel, check your state and local rules and with the land manager, get the landowner's permission on private land, and get the claimholder's permission before working any mining claim.

Which one should you choose?

Your situation Consider
Gold is in the stream bed, under water Backpack or 2.5 in dredge, or a combo
Gravel is on the bank or away from the water Highbanker / power sluice with a gas pump
You want one machine for both Proline or Keene dredge/highbanker combo
Material is clay-bound, rooty or packed Trommel feeding a sluice
You prefer battery power, or gas engines aren't allowed 12-volt highbanker or the Keene KT10DC trommel
You want to hike in light Keene Mini Max, Gold Hog Piglet, or a hand dredge

Browse every model on our gold dredges and highbankers page.

FAQ

What's the difference between a highbanker and a dredge?

A dredge sucks gravel up from under water with a suction hose. A highbanker pumps water to a hopper so you can shovel or bucket-feed gravel, often away from the water. Combo machines can do both.

What size dredge should a beginner get?

Proline says beginners love 2 in machines because they're small, lightweight and very affordable. Its 2.5 in combo is the smallest that can be continuously fed with a standard shovel.

Do I need a trommel?

Not always. Trommels like the Keene KT10 are built for tough material: heavy clay, rooty dirt and packed gravel. Our general advice is to start with a classifier and a sluice or highbanker, and to look at a trommel if your material won't wash clean without one.